If you purchase an independently reviewed product or service through a link on our website, WWD may receive an affiliate commission.
Contents
In this article
Editor’s Note: The prices shown here for each engagement ring style are based on diamond parameters — like carat weight, natural or lab-grown sourcing, and clarity — that were chosen by our editors for the sake of showing you the wide range of options available online. You can adjust each parameter to your liking, which will change the ring costs accordingly.
Depending on who you ask, you’re going to get a different answer every time on what the top engagement ring brands are in 2026. Much like some women prefer emerald-cut stones whereas others fancy classic, round diamonds, so too does each couple have their own take on if it’s best to shop for an engagement ring online or stick to tradition: picking out your forever ring at a jeweler’s brick-and-mortar storefront. Our opinion? It is wise to look for and commit to the best engagement rings on the internet, especially if you have a clear idea about the 4Cs (cut, clarity, color, and carat), know the band design and metal type that managed to steal your breath away, and can recite your ideal diamond shape in your sleep.
These days, online engagement ring brands like Blue Nile provide state-of-the-art shopping experiences from the comforts of home: allowing you to curate a dream ring from start to finish, beginning with the setting or stone silhouette. For those who are still on the fence looks-wise, the best engagement ring retailers also specialize in ready-to-ship rings. All you have to do is choose the appropriate ring size and have the captivating object on its way to your door in a heartbeat (sometimes delivery is as fast as overnight, for the impatient and madly in love among us).
Finding the ring? Easier said than done, but the best online jewelers are here to help you every step of the way.
Courtesy Blue Nile
Every engagement ring company featured below has its own strong suits. Blue Nile, for instance, comes with the benefit of 360-degree diamond visualization technology as part of its Creative Studio. You can twist any given ring this way and that, evaluating it from all angles; if something doesn’t look flawless in your opinion, making a shape, carat weight, prong style, or shank style change is easy as can be. Because engagement ring shopping should be simple (which is not to say it’s not important: perhaps the most important thing you’ll do in your life) in context of all the hurdles you’ll soon face when wedding planning.
Think the human element will be absent from the process of buying a ring online versus IRL? Think again. We’ve carefully researched our recommendations, ensuring they all come with hyper-responsive customer support should you have questions related to sizing, inventory, warranties, or another topic entirely. Some brands, like the aforementioned Blue Nile, even take it one step further — what with their virtual showroom appointments during which you can get a one-on-one consultation with an in-house diamond expert, while “multiple cameras highligh[t] the jewelry from many angles.”
Another major point of deliberation in this endeavor is whether to go natural, as opposed to lab-grown, when it comes to how the gem itself is sourced. Each type of diamond has its pros and cons, but rest assured that whatever decision you and yours end up making, the best online engagement ring stores will be well-stocked with both.
Have a flair for the high-end? We’d be remiss not to point you to the dozens of designer engagement ring selections available on the world wide web. Look no further than Zac Posen’s Bypass Solitaire Engagement Ring in 14K White Gold at Blue Nile, joined by bestsellers from Brilliant Earth’s Tacori collection (the California-based jewelry house is considered cream of the crop for handcrafted engagement rings) and other elevated pieces.
Chances are, once you find “the one” (we’re not talking about your future fiancé here, by the way) at a trusted and beloved ring destination, you’ll turn to it for your wedding band shopping, too.
Without further ado, the best places to shop for engagement rings, as well as the exact rings that have caught our eye. They’ll be there for you from “yes” to “I do” and across a lifetime of love. What could be more romantic than that?
Sign up for WWD Shop‘s newsletter to get the scoop on the best in beauty and style with in-depth reviews of exciting new releases and buyer’s guides to find the products you need to try ASAP.
Blue Nile
The founded-in-1999 Blue Nile is the O.G. in online jewelry shopping — merging trustworthy, responsive service with top-quality manufacturing and trend-aligned aesthetics. Every last one of its diamonds is responsibly sourced, and Blue Nile gives shoppers further peace of mind with price-match guarantees, diamond grading reports, and what it calls “interactive viewing tools” that let you get so up-close-and-personal to the ring, you’ll never go back to an in-person showroom again.
What we also love: Blue Nile is ready to meet you where you’re at, meaning those who are still in the “I’m contemplating” stage can take advantage of the online Engagement Ring Guide. It walks couples through budget considerations; trending metals; the difference between prong-style and bezel settings; what the most vital of the 4Cs is; how to determine your ring size (Blue Nile has a handy printable guide, but you can also order a free ring sizer from the site); and other criteria.
With the diamond destination’s Creative Studio, you can also achieve a previously unheard-of level of intimacy with an engagement ring online — having every single permutation of ring possible within easy reach. Before hopping over to Blue Nile, we, for one, didn’t know how a Surprise Diamond setting even looked like or what the difference between a Vintage Trefoil head and a Classic Basket head was.
Blue Nile has one of the most robust assortments of natural diamonds we’ve seen anywhere online. After choosing shape (everything from princess to the vintage-inspired Asscher is fair game here), you can toggle the price parameters, carat weight, color, clarity, and cut; in seconds, a range of loose diamonds will pop up on-screen. Note that they all follow the strict standards of the Kimberley Process, an international regime that champions conflict-free diamond trade.
Here are the three best natural diamond engagement rings from Blue Nile that we simply can’t turn away from. If my boyfriend is reading this, take screenshots!
Blue Nile Riviera Cathedral Pavé Engagement Ring
Price upon publish date of this article: $5,731
Blue Nile Three-Stone Engagement Ring
Price upon publish date of this article: $15,434
Blue Nile Classic Four Prong Solitaire Engagement Ring
Price upon publish date of this article: $8,245
James Allen Collection
James Allen, another leading online engagement ring retailer, has joined the Blue Nile family as an exclusive collection. What this means: You’ll enjoy the same high-quality views and trustworthy customer service for your virtual shopping journey, plus a wide selection of natural and lab-grown diamonds to choose from.
The James Allen Collection brings added range to the assortment, offering engagement rings in a variety of styles and settings. The collection is designed to give shoppers freedom in how they approach the ring-buying process — whether they’re prioritizing diamond type or price point. In that, it emphasizes choice without sacrificing quality and thereby makes it easier to find something that feels personal from the start.
Looking beyond a one-size-fits-all experience? The James Allen Collection focuses on infusing classic engagement rings with a fresher POV. The lineup features timeless solitaires as well as pavé, halo, and three-stone settings, giving you wiggle room to explore different visual narratives while maintaining a cohesive, upscale look.
And should you need further inspiration before getting down on one knee, we got you with these top-selling beauts for every kind of woman.
Leaf Vine Diamond Motif Side Stone Engagement Ring by James Allen
Price upon publish date of this article: $3,440
Star Diamond Halo Cathedral Engagement Ring by James Allen
Price upon publish date of this article: $5,760
Oculus Solitaire Engagement Ring by James Allen
Price upon publish date of this article: $4,160
Frank Darling
Circa-2017 fine jewelry maker Frank Darling is particularly loved by NYC-residing women with high standards (maybe due to the fact that it has three whole showrooms in the city). But you don’t have to live in the Big Apple to shop Frank Darling’s “custom, not complicated” creations. The pièce de résistance of the brand’s business model is that it only uses 100-percent recycled gold, and it’s also worth pointing out the rare-in-the-industry “try at home” feature, which delivers to your door three sterling-silver replica rings that can be kept for five days. After you don them to work, the gym, and happy-hour drinks, you’ll have a clearer sense of whether the style deserves the commitment. And you’d know all about commitment!
If you have a soft spot for all things vintage (à la the old mine diamond blessing Taylor Swift‘s ring finger as we speak), Frank Darling comes in clutch with a surprisingly full roster of rings that are antidotes to modernity. Old mine gems are spotlighted front and center, and so are old European cuts. Popularized in 19th-century Europe, they swap blinding sparkle for multi-hued flashes of light and flaunt the kinds of quirks that will make you feel like you have a one-of-a-kind engagement ring. PSA: You soon will.
To be sure, you can also go as contemporary-coded as your heart desires at Frank Darling — which backs its pieces with a lifetime warranty on defects like loose stones, one free resize within 90 days of delivery, and flexible payment options so that nothing gets in the way between you and the next step in your love story.
Frank Darling The Millie Three Stone Engagement Ring
Price upon publish date of this article: $4,021.50
Frank Darling The Cathedral Pavé Engagement Ring
Price upon publish date of this article: $3,750
Frank Darling The Hourglass Engagement Ring
Price upon publish date of this article: $4,580
Brilliant Earth
Go ahead, make it official with the help of Brilliant Earth’s magic. The brand was launched in 2005 and is lauded for its ethical sourcing, circularity in production, stunning designs dreamt up by masters of their craft, and the opportunity it gives clients for complete, A to Z (erm, C to C) customization. Like Blue Nile, Brilliant Earth also has virtual showroom appointments that take place via video call. A Brilliant Earth jewelry specialist will give you 50 minutes of their time in this case — educating and guiding without pressure while pointing you to the best-of-the-best diamonds and styles.
Special, ornate collections like the Camellia, Aimee, and (our favorite) Secret Garden will scratch the itch of every “Bridgerton”–obsessed bride-to-be. At the same time, Brilliant Earth collaborations with the likes of the previously mentioned Tacori pamper customers with striking arrangements that promise to shine “from every angle” — no matter if you seal the deal on a three-stone or a more-is-more, halo-plus-pavé ring.
Brilliant Earth also stands out from the crowd by way of its Bridal Set section. Many women run into problems when the time finally comes to wear their engagement ring with a wedding band, since the two oftentimes end up being a less-than-ideal match. With its sets, Brilliant Earth takes the guesswork out of trying to get the pairing right. Look for the tags “Perfect Match” and “Most Loved” when deciding which ring duo is meant for you… and will spare you from any last-minute alterations.
Taking it one step at a time in terms of ring shopping? Cheers to that. Here are the top engagement rings you should be grabbing at Brilliant Earth this year — regardless of when the wedding is slated for.
Brilliant Earth Secret Garden Engagement Ring
Price upon publish date of this article: $16,200
Brilliant Earth Luxe Willow Halo Engagement Ring
Price upon publish date of this article: $9,000
Why Trust WWD
Since 1910, WWD — often referred to as “the fashion bible” — has been the leading industry voice of authority for senior executives in the global women’s and men’s fashion, retail and beauty communities, while also informing the consumer media that cover the market. Today, WWD’s breaking news and trend coverage continues to be a trustworthy resource for both fashion insiders and consumers alike. Our shopping editors continue to uphold WWD’s editorial standards and values with quality, expert-backed product selections. Learn more about us here.
Stacia Datskovska is a Senior Commerce Writer at WWD. Previously, she worked at ELLE DECOR as an assistant digital editor, covering all things luxury, culture, and lifestyle through a design lens. Her bylines over the past five years have appeared in USA Today, Baltimore Sun, Teen Vogue, Boston Globe, Food & Wine, and more. Prior to joining ELLE DECOR, Datskovska learned the ins and outs of e-commerce at Mashable, where she tested products, covered tentpole sales events, and curated gift guide roundups. She graduated from NYU with a bachelor’s degree in journalism and international relations. Datskovska regularly reports on jewelry trends, including in the engagement ring space, and how to shop them.
