Eyeliner is one of my favorite products to use, whether I’m doing a cat-eye, tight-lining my upper waterline for a smudged, smoky effect, or adding a pop of color with a bright blue or bright white. A black pencil is a staple, so I wanted to see how Jones Road’s stacked up. It’s challenging — borderline impossible — to achieve an intense, inky black with a “clean” product due to the absence of carbon pigments typically found in conventional black eyeliners. Thus, I wasn’t surprised that Jones Road’s pencil came out as soft black. Using small strokes, I lined the outer corner of my eyes and blended it out to create the littlest wing. (I almost never line my entire lash line since it can make my eyes look smaller.) For subtle definition, this pencil gets the job done, and I appreciate that it’s a clean formula safe for the delicate eye area. However, if you’re after a dramatic, long-wear, or waterproof formula, this might not be the best choice.
